In case you missed it see what’s in this section
We recommend
Let's Talk
Your Total Guide To business
The Metrics That Matter Are Changing (And That’s a Good Thing)
For the first time in a long time, we’re having a different kind of conversation with clients.
“Yes, Google referral traffic is down.”
“Yes, clicks look different.”
“And no – we’re not worried.”
Because the way people discover, decide and book has fundamentally changed.
AI-powered search, social platforms, comments, tags, shares, saves and DMs are now doing a huge amount of the heavy lifting – often before someone ever clicks a website link.
Clicks aren’t disappearing – they’re just no longer the full story
We’re seeing this across Total Guide to channels.
While some referral traffic has softened, engagement has surged in a far more meaningful way:
- People tagging friends saying “we need to book this”
- Comment threads asking “is this worth it?” and getting peer-to-peer answers
- DMs requesting links, menus, dates and availability
- Posts being saved, shared and screenshot (yes, really)
That behaviour signals high intent.
And here’s the key point: A public social recommendation from a friend is often more powerful than a click-through from Google.
Why traditional reporting can feel uncomfortable right now
For years, success was easy to measure:
- Page views
- Clicks
- Referral traffic
But AI search often answers questions without a click. Social platforms reward keeping users on-platform. And consumers increasingly trust people over pages.
If you’re only measuring performance by traffic alone, it can feel like something is “dropping” – when in reality, influence and intent are rising.
Visibility + influence now matter as much as visits
The brands winning right now are:
- Showing up where decisions are actually happening
- Being part of conversations, not just search results
- Creating content that sparks tagging, saving and sharing
- Being recommended before someone Googles
A truly varied approach – storytelling via socials and content, AI-search visibility, community-led engagement rather than one-way posting, influencer and peer recommendation, and relationship-driven networking that builds long-term trust.
That’s not a loss of value – it’s a shift in how value is created.
So how should businesses measure success in 2026?
It’s time to broaden the lens:
- Engagement quality over volume
- Comments, tags and shares over raw clicks
- Brand mentions and visibility across AI search
- Social proof and recommendation signals
- Enquiries that say “I saw you on Instagram/TikTok/Facebook/LinkedIn” or “you were tagged”
- Clicks still matter – but they’re no longer the hero metric.
What we’re helping clients focus on next
At Total Guide, we’re leaning into this shift, not fighting it.
That’s why we’re:
- Running AI Search Audits to see how businesses show up in AI-led discovery
- Doubling down on social-first content and influencer-led recommendations
- Creating content designed to be shared, tagged and talked about
- Reporting on visibility, influence and intent – not just traffic
Because the future isn’t about chasing clicks. It’s about being chosen.
If you're curious how your business shows up in AI search and conversational discovery?
Our AI Search Audits reveal where you’re visible, where you’re missing, and how to adapt. Message Liz on 07814080119 or email [email protected].
Discover how ChatGPT can boost your paid search strategy by visiting our latest blog here.
Author Bio - Liz Hutchings
Liz Hutchings is the Founder and Managing Director of Total Guide to and Total Marketing, where she helps brands stay visible, relevant and chosen in a rapidly changing digital landscape.
With years of hands-on experience across content, social, SEO and community-led marketing, Liz focuses on what actually drives intent today, influence, recommendation and trust, not vanity metrics. Her work centres on AI-led discovery, social-first storytelling and measurable engagement that reflects how people really discover and decide in 2026.
Liz regularly shares practical insight on how businesses can adapt to changing search behaviour, shifting platforms and evolving consumer decision-making.
Helpful Resources
- ChatGPT Paid Search Guide
- 8 SEO Trends Defining 2026
- Should You Change Your SEO Strategy for AI Search Results?
Everything You Need to Know About Modern Marketing Metrics
How can social engagement signal high buying intent?
Comments, tags, shares, saves, and DMs indicate people are considering your product or service. Peer recommendations often carry more weight than a Google click.
What is AI-led discovery, and why does it matter for my business?
AI-led discovery is when search engines and platforms provide answers or recommendations without a click. It changes how consumers find your brand and requires a focus on visibility and influence, not just traffic.
How should businesses measure success in 2026?
By tracking engagement quality, brand mentions, social proof, AI search visibility, and peer-to-peer recommendations, not only page views or referral traffic.
What is an AI Search Audit, and how can it help my brand?
An AI Search Audit evaluates how your business shows up in AI-powered search and conversational discovery. It identifies gaps and opportunities to increase visibility where decisions are actually happening.
How do social-first strategies benefit marketing today?
Social-first strategies focus on content designed to be shared, tagged, and recommended. They create real-world influence, build trust, and drive intent, often before someone searches on Google.
Should I still focus on SEO and clicks?
Yes, clicks still matter, but they’re no longer the only measure of success. Combining SEO with social influence, AI visibility, and community engagement creates a more complete picture of performance.
What types of engagement indicate people are “ready to buy”?
Peer tags, comments asking for advice, DMs requesting links or availability, and posts saved or shared are strong indicators of high-intent behavior.
Weather in Bath
Listings